Questionable Leadership

The right questions about the wrong things

Questionable Leadership

The right questions about the wrong things

Think about the last question you asked your team. What did it set in motion?

The questions leaders ask shape what gets noticed, what gets measured and, ultimately, what people spend their time doing. That makes them a powerful strategic tool, particularly when the world around us is changing so quickly.

In this edition of Moments That Matter, I explore the relationship between the questions we ask, the things we choose to focus on and the consequences of getting either one wrong.

Read here

One of the things I teach leaders is that the questions they ask is one of the most powerful strategic levers available to them.

Particularly for senior leaders, whose positional power gives their questions considerable reach. Ask a question in an executive meeting and you influence what people pay attention to, what information gets gathered, what appears in operational plans and, eventually, what teams and individuals spend their time doing.

That's quite a lot of influence for something that can take less than ten seconds to say.

Which is why it’s worth considering whether we're asking the right questions, and if we’re asking them about the right things.

As leadership teams begin planning for 2027, many will be revisiting familiar questions about growth, productivity, resources and priorities. They're reasonable questions, and some will be exactly what the organisation needs. But others may have been carried forward from a time when the circumstances were quite different.

The difficulty is that questions don’t look or feel outdated. They're often embedded in strategic plans, reporting structures and performance measures, and we've become rather good at answering them. An organisation can be making measurable progress against its priorities without noticing that something else, of more consequence now deserves its attention.

There are two things worth looking at here. The first is whether we've recognised what matters most in the context we're now operating in. The second is whether we're asking questions that will help us understand and respond to it.

And we can get either one wrong.

Consider AI. Most senior leadership teams recognise that it is changing the conditions in which their organisations operate. They understand that it deserves attention, and increasingly it has a place on the strategic agenda.

But what happens once it's there?

The conversation can move quite quickly to which tools to adopt, where to automate work, what productivity gains might be possible and how to manage the associated risks. These are legitimate questions, although they may not be the ones that most need attention first.

What if AI is changing what customers will value, how expertise develops or the capabilities the organisation will need to remain successful? A leadership team could make excellent decisions about implementation while leaving those more consequential questions largely unexplored.

In this case, the team has recognised the right thing but may be asking the wrong questions about it.

The reverse is possible too. A team might be asking thoughtful, rigorous questions about improving its existing operating model while failing to recognise that the model itself is becoming less relevant. The questions are good, but they're focused on something that no longer deserves quite so much attention.

And, of course, it's possible to be wrong about both.

This is where Cognitive Independence becomes relevant. Awareness includes recognising when the assumptions through which we're interpreting our circumstances may no longer hold. Agency allows us to reconsider the direction we're taking, and Accountability keeps us connected to the impact and outcomes of our decisions and what we learn from them.

For leadership teams, that requires collective discernment about both the context and the questions being asked. It also means being willing to reconsider the questions that have shaped previous decisions, even when those decisions were entirely reasonable at the time.

Finding the right conversation sometimes begins with examining the one we've arrived prepared to have.

And given how far senior leader questions can travel through an organisation, I reckon that's worth doing before everyone gets busy answering the wrong one.

Archive