Untangling Complexity
The trouble with being right about what’s wrong

Untangling Complexity
The trouble with being right about what’s wrong
How do we keep doing right by the people in front of us while trying to change the systems that are making things harder for them?
In this edition of Moments That Matter, we explore how to judge where to direct our attention and energy when the problems we're facing are bigger than our immediate ability to influence them, and how to decide what will actually make a difference.
Listen here
Read here
In complex systems, we can be entirely right about what's wrong and still be ineffective in what we do about it.
Recognising an unfair system, an unhelpful structure or a policy that needs changing is important. But knowing what needs to change doesn't necessarily tell us where or how to act, or how much of our limited energy to devote to it. And that's not always easy to judge when we're right in the middle of it.
Schools are useful places to see this in action. Most of us have experienced them as students, parents, or both, and know how quickly an apparently simple issue becomes entangled with everything else. Decisions made well beyond the school gate can have very immediate consequences for the people inside it.
Take a school leader who believes a policy governing learning support is unfair. They see the consequences in classrooms, in teacher workloads and in children whose needs aren't being met. They may have raised their concerns repeatedly, with good reason. The policy sits beyond their authority, but its impact walks through the school gate every morning.
What does good leadership look like in that situation?
One of the things we teach people is to focus on what they can influence. The Circles of Control framework from Stoicism is helpful here. It encourages us to distinguish between what we can change directly, what we might be able to influence and what sits beyond our reach. I use it often, particularly when people are feeling overwhelmed by everything happening around them.
But I think this need handling with care.
Some of the most consequential changes in organisations and societies begin when people refuse to accept the existing boundaries of their influence, and those boundaries can shift. What begins beyond one person's influence may become possible through collective action. There's real value in that kind of activism, in being prepared to challenge something that isn't working and work towards changing it.
But I've also seen the other side of this. People can spend so much energy and attention railing against an unfair system or structure that they burn themselves out, leaving little for the responsibilities directly in front of them. They may be absolutely right about the unfairness, and entirely justified in their frustration. Meanwhile, the people depending on them still need their attention, care and judgement.
For our school leader, the teachers still need support and the children still need to learn. There may be things the school can do now to reduce the impact of the policy: adapt how resources are allocated, improve conversations between teachers and families, or change a practice that's making an already difficult situation harder. None of that makes the policy fair, and it certainly doesn't mean giving up the effort to change it.
This is a great example of the well-used premise - 'think global, act local' - the leader keeps sight of the wider system while doing something locally where they have agency. And that strategy is useful. To a point.
Sometimes local action won't be enough, and sometimes we assume that because the problem is large, our response has to be large too. They may both be right… and wrong.
The scale of the problem, the scale of our influence and the scale at which an intervention will make a difference can be three different things.
What could this look like?
In our school, for the child who isn't receiving what they need, an effective intervention might be a conversation between student, teacher and parent, followed by a practical change in the classroom. If the same issue keeps arising across the school, it may need a different response in terms of how staff organise learning support. And if a policy is affecting hundreds of schools, individual workarounds may help children today, but lasting change may require coordinated action well beyond any one school.
All of those responses can matter. The judgement here is in recognising which one is needed, and what we're realistically able to do about it.
Because alongside this is the important question of capacity. Energy and attention are finite, and leaders are often juggling responsibilities at several levels at once. The challenge is to work towards changing a larger system while also protecting enough of ourselves to meet the needs of the work directly in front of us. Sometimes that means involving others, working to a different timescale, adjusting an intervention that isn't working, or stepping away from an argument that's generating more heat than movement.
I know from experience that this is one of the harder parts of leading through complexity.
Our school leader can be entirely justified in challenging an unfair policy and still find that the effort has left them with less patience for the teacher who needs support or the parent who needs an answer. And those people are living with the consequences of the very system the leader is trying to change.
Navigating complexity means seeing enough of the whole to understand what's producing the problem, without becoming so consumed by it that we have little left for the people living with its consequences.
And we need to keep asking whether the action we're taking, at whatever scale, is making a difference with the people we need it to.
